The history of the study of mediation institutions in Kazakhstan

Issue 55, 2024

Zhansaya Kenzhebekova, Gulnara Musabalina

Received 23.09.2023, Revised 14.12.2023, Accepted 26.02.2024

https://doi.org/10.54919/physics/55.2024.139us6

Abstract

Relevance. Mediation is one of the most dynamically developing legal institutions in the modern world. Due to the fact that traditional methods of resolving disputes remain ineffective and do not always satisfy the parties with their results, the use of such an alternative method as mediation allows resolving the conflict at the pre-trial stage in a peaceful way. The need for a comprehensive implementation of the institution of mediation in the life of Kazakhstani society, as promising and necessary in modern conditions, determines the relevance of the study. The history of the study of mediation institutions has not been subjected to special scientific research. The coverage of the problems of the historical development of mediation in Kazakhstan from the court of biys to the modern institution of mediation is the scientific novelty of this article.

Purpose. The purpose of the study is to study the history of the development of mediation institutions in Kazakhstan.

Methodology. Various methods were used for the study, such as descriptive, comparative historical-critical, methods of analysis, synthesis, dialectical method of scientific knowledge.

Results. In the course of the study, it was concluded that despite its apparent unconventionality and modernity, mediation has a long history and deep roots in Kazakh society. A function similar to mediation in the XVIII-XIX centuries was performed by the court of biys, forcibly liquidated by the imperial administration in the 2nd half of the XIX century.

Conclusions. The establishment of a modern institution of mediation in Kazakhstan in 2011 should in part be considered a revival of old traditions. Most scientists dealing with this problem agree that mediation in Kazakhstan needs to be developed, as well as to expand its use in various fields, taking into account both international experience and the traditions and mentality of the Kazakh people.

Keywords: alternative ways of resolving disputes; legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan; biy court; mediation; reconciliation of the parties

Suggested citation

Kenzhebekova Z, Musabalina G. The history of the study of mediation institutions in Kazakhstan. Sci Herald Uzhhorod Univ Ser Phys. 2024;(55):1396-1404. DOI: 10.54919/physics/55.2024.139us6

Download article

References

  1. Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan No. 401-IV “On mediation”. 2011. https://online.zakon.kz/Document/?doc_id=30927376
  2. Shamshinurova SM. Independent court: history and modernity. Bull Inst Legis Legal Info Repub Kazak. 2014;1(33):182-187.
  3. Dalmatov KZ. Justice and prosecutorial supervision in Kazakhstan as part of the Russian Empire in the second half of the XIX century. Bull Inst Legis Legal Info Repub Kazak. 2020;1(59):340-344.
  4. Mitskaya EV. Pre-trial mediation in criminal cases: State and development prospects. Bull Inst Legis Legal Info Repub Kazak. 2019;4(58):71-80.
  5. Dyachuk MI. Development of the institution of mediation in the Republic of Kazakhstan. Bull Inst Legis Legal Info Repub Kazak. 2021;1(64):219-232.
  6. Velitchenko SN. Development of mediation in Kazakhstan: Problems and solutions. Int Res J. 2013;9-3(16):5-6.
  7. Ospanova D. Mediation issues in the Republic of Kazakhstan. InterConf. 2021;42:583-587.
  8. Domenici K, Littlejohn SW. Mediation: Empowerment in conflict management. Long Grove: Waveland Press; 2001.
  9. Agardy P. Mediation and the insolvency practitioner. Insolv Law J. 2009;17(3):135-146.
  10. Winslade J, Monk G. Narrative mediation: A new approach to conflict resolution. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers; 2000.
  11. Vinogradova EV, Oganezova AV. Alternative dispute resolution in the countries of the Eurasian Economic Union: Mediation. Euras Advoc. 2020;1(44):52-56.
  12. Kyrdan B. International standards for mediation. German Int J Modern Sci. 2022;26:39-41.
  13. Ozmumcu S. An overview of mediation in the far east and the mediation institution in the Turkish legal system. Istanbul: On Iki Levha Yayincilik A.S; 2013.
  14. Kinikoglu E, Parmaksiz Y, Solak H. Mediation Q&A: Turkey. Pract Law Count. 2020;6:1-18.
  15. Mediation developments in Turkey. 2020. https://weinsteininternational.org/turkey/turkey-bio/
  16. Fan K. Mediation of investor-state disputes: A treaty survey. J Disput Resolut. 2020;2020(2):327-342.
  17. Wegmann B. Mediation in notarial practice: Alternative ways to resolve conflicts. Alphen aan den Rijn: Wolters Kluwer; 2005.
  18. Kerimkhulle S, Aitkozha Z, Saliyeva A, Kerimkulov Z, Adalbek A, Taberkhan R. Agriculture, Hunting, Forestry, and Fishing Industry of Kazakhstan Economy: Input-Output Analysis. Lect Not Networks Syst. 2023;596:786-797.
  19. Tanaka M, Desai D, Fujiwara Y, Arataki S, Latka K, Sake N, Liang W, Kodama Y, Miyamoto Y, Yamauchi T. Effect of an Adjustable Hinged Carbon Fiber Operating Table on Sagittal Alignment of the Lumbar Spine. Appl Sci (Switz). 2023;13(1):138.
  20. Nabiyeva DD. The role of the institution of mediation in alternative dispute resolution. Orient Renais: Innov, Educ, Natur Social Sci. 2022;2(4-2):1084-1088.
  21. Pochekaev RY. The main stages of the evolution of the Kazakh biy court (XV – early XX centuries). Sanger. 2008;4(81):51-60.
  22. Latka K, Kozlowska K, Waligora M, Kolodziej W, Latka D. Effect of DiscoGel treatment of the intervertebral disc at MRI. Clin Radiol. 2023;78(12):928-934.
  23. Abdrasulov EB. The role of the court of biys in improving the norms of customary law. Almaty: Zheti Zhargy; 2008.
  24. Biliuk I, Shareyko D, Savchenko O, Havrylov S, Fomenko A, Tubaltsev A. Machine Calculation of the Problem of Expansion of the Magnetic Field Measurement Grid. In: Proceedings of the 5th International Conference on Modern Electrical and Energy System, MEES 2023. Kremenchuk: Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers; 2023.
  25. Central State Archive of the Republic of Kazakhstan. File 4. Inventory 1. Case 2382. Page 103.
  26. Central State Archive of the Republic of Kazakhstan. File 369. Inventory 1. Case 1. Page 124.
  27. Central State Archive of the Republic of Kazakhstan. File 4. Inventory 1. Case 1. Paper 58.
  28. Central State Archive of the Republic of Kazakhstan. File 4. Inventory 1. Case 1. Paper 193.
  29. Central State Archive of the Republic of Kazakhstan. File 4. Inventory 1. Case 4957. Paper 42.
  30. Central State Archive of the Republic of Kazakhstan. File 4. Inventory 1. Case 12. Paper 9.
  31. Central State Archive of the Republic of Kazakhstan. File 4. Inventory 1. Case 14. Papers 1-3.
  32. Central State Archive of the Republic of Kazakhstan. File 4. Inventory 1. Case 4659. Papers 2-10.
  33. Central State Archive of the Republic of Kazakhstan. File 345. Inventory 1. Case 1456. Paper 11.
  34. Central State Archive of the Republic of Kazakhstan. File 345. Inventory 1. Case 807. Paper 1.
  35. Kerimkhulle S, Saliyeva A, Makhazhanova U, Kerimkulov Z, Adalbek A, Taberkhan R. The input-output analysis for the wholesale and retail trade industry of the Kazakhstan statistics. E3S Web Conf. 2023;376:05023.
  36. Lieberman E, Foux-Levy Y, Segala P. Beyond basic training: Model for developing mediator competence. Conf Resolut Quart. 2005;23(2):237-257.
  37. Yerzhanova AE, Kerimkhulle SY, Abdikerimova GB, Makhanov M, Beglerova ST, Taszhurekova ZK. Atmospheric correction of landsat-8 / Oli data using the flaash algorithm: Obtaining information about agricultural crops. J Theoret Appl Inf Tech. 2021;99(13):3110-3119.
  38. Bieliatynskyi A, Yang S, Pershakov V, Shao M, Ta M. The use of fiber made from fly ash from power plants in China in road and airfield construction. Construct Build Mater. 2022;323:126537.
  39. Mazakova A, Jomartova S, Mazakov T, Shormanov T, Amirkhanov B. Controllability of an unmanned aerial vehicle. In: ENERGYCON 2022 - 2022 IEEE 7th International Energy Conference, Proceedings. Riga: Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers. 2022. DOI: 10.1109/ENERGYCON53164.2022.9830244
  40. Uderbaeva SK. Integration of Kazakh officials into the administrative apparatus of the Russian Empire (XIX-XX centuries). Rep Nation Academ Sci Repub Kazak. 2014;3:171-175.
  41. Mazakov T, Jomartova S, Ziyatbekova G, Aliaskar M. Automated system for monitoring the threat of waterworks breakout. J Theoret Appl Inf Tech. 2020;98(15):3176-3189.
  42. Latka K, Kolodziej W, Domisiewicz K, Pawus D, Olbrycht T, Niedzwiecki M, Zaczynski A, Latka D. Outpatient Spine Procedures in Poland: Clinical Outcomes, Safety, Complications, and Technical Insights into an Ambulatory Spine Surgery Center. Healthcare (Switz). 2023;11(22):2944.
  43. Begmatova SM. The concept and principles of “mediation”. Orient Renais: Innov, Educ, Natur Social Sci. 2022;2(9):619-626.
  44. Zimanov SZ. Kazakh biy court – a general cultural value. Almaty: Arys; 2009.
Make a Submission

Indexing

info@physics.uz.ua